WHERE WE STAND:For the average New Jerseyan, sizable property tax credit will return more money.
Big talk about tax reductions should be music to most New Jerseyans’ ears ... if they believe the governor and their legislators. Trust politicians? OK, let’s not get too excited.
But if it does happen, which form of tax relief is best for New Jersey? We don’t think there’s much to argue.
While a reduction of the state income tax, proposed by Republican Gov. Chris Christie, would be welcome, a reduction of property taxes (really money back to taxpayers based on their property taxes) would be better. Why? It is property taxes, now approaching $7,900 a year for the average New Jersey homeowner, that cause the most pain for residents, particularly seniors and others on fixed incomes.
So, in considering the options, we think the Democrats’ plan for a property tax credit of at least 10 percent is what should come to fruition.
State Senate President Stephen Sweeney, D-Gloucester is pitching a plan that would be a credit of 10 percent on property taxes (up to $1,000) for households earning less than $250,000. Democratic leaders in the state Assembly, including Majority Leader Louis Greenwald, D-Camden, are pitching a plan that calls for a credit of up to 20 percent on property taxes. The big difference between the two plans (besides the percentage) is that Greenwald’s calls for raising the income tax rate on millionaires in New Jersey while Sweeney’s plan doesn’t.
Christie has rejected Democratic plans to re-institute the “millionaire’s tax” before and has vowed to do so again. GOP legislators support him. So the reality is that the millionaire’s tax isn’t going to happen.
But property tax relief in the form of credits against income taxes should happen. If it’s 10 percent, great. If compromise gets it to more than that somehow, even better.
Do the math and it’s simple: a New Jersey couple, who have taxable income of $100,000, based on the 2011 state income tax rate schedule, would pay $2,750. Slash 10 percent with an income tax cut and they save $275.
Say that couple live in a home with property taxes of $7,000 a year, under the state average. Give them 10 percent against that and they’re saving $700.
All sides are posturing here, playing to various audiences and not talking about all the fine print in their plans. And if they wanted to truly fix our state’s great tax problem rather than just put on Band Aids, they’d work on shifting much of the burden of paying for government services away from property taxes.
Assuming they still don’t have the courage to start that process, a property credit of at least 10 percent will help more New Jerseyans who truly need tax relief than will Christie’s income tax cut. So deliver the property tax relief Band Aid in 2012.